Lea, mine was perfect, first time out. I preordered from Ingrid, so I think it was here the day after Labor Day. The riding habits (both) & Elizabeth's nightgown were the ONLY things I didn't exchange. Noah's Ark was missing a piggie, so the 2nd one was complete. Everything else went back twice. I still haven't reordered.

My Mattel Felicity is pictured in E's habit in the link on my Felicity post. It's really, really pretty.